| Abyssal FangtoothLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Rare | 7.4% |
| AnglerfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Epic | 2.18% |
| Arctic GraylingBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Epic | 1% |
| Ashen CarpInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Common | 6.66% |
| Atlantic HerringPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 15.9% |
| Aurate TunaInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Common | 15.8% |
| Azure CatfishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Rare | 8.29% |
| Azure Reef FishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Rare | 3.6% |
| Azure SeahorseLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Epic | 1.53% |
| Azure SwordfishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Common | 12.3% |
| BassFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Common | 10.5% |
| Blaze EelInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Epic | 2% |
| Blaze SharkInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Epic | 1.25% |
| Blazing PufferInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Legendary | 1 in 33,333 |
| Blue Brick FishClassic Island | Classic Island | Common | 12.3% |
| Blue LoachBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Rare | 4.92% |
| Blue MarlinPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 8.2% |
| Brick PufferClassic Island | Classic Island | Epic | 2% |
| CatfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Rare | 6% |
| ClamLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Epic | 1.25% |
| Classic Clown ClownfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Epic | 1 in 111 |
| Classic ClownfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Rare | 8.29% |
| Classic CrownfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Epic | 1.25% |
| Classic Cthulhu's EyeClassic Island | Classic Island | Legendary | 1 in 100,000 |
| Classic Dark ClownfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Rare | 5.14% |
| Classic FlatfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Epic | 1.53% |
| Classic JellyfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Legendary | 1 in 200,000 |
| Classic MinnowClassic Island | Classic Island | Rare | 6.86% |
| Classic Neon SharkClassic Island | Classic Island | Rare | 3.6% |
| Classic Rainbow ClownfishClassic Island | Classic Island | Legendary | 1 in 2,000 |
| Classic Rainbow SharkClassic Island | Classic Island | Legendary | 1 in 1,000 |
| Classic SharkClassic Island | Classic Island | Rare | 7.4% |
| Classic SquidClassic Island | Classic Island | Legendary | 1 in 50,000 |
| ClownfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 9.8% |
| CodFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Rare | 4.86% |
| Cold CrystalfishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Epic | 2.7% |
| Commander SpearfishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Legendary | 1 in 200 |
| Common FangtoothPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Rare | 6.3% |
| Coral CarpPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 8.44% |
| Crystal ClownfishBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Rare | 4.43% |
| CrystalfishBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Rare | 4.11% |
| Cthulhu's EyeLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Legendary | 1 in 13,333 |
| Deep Dark SailfishLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Rare | 6.86% |
| Dream PufferDream Island | Dream Island | Common | 17.8% |
| DreamerfishDream Island | Dream Island | Common | 12.3% |
| Dreamy ClownfishDream Island | Dream Island | Common | 11.7% |
| Dreamy Reef FishDream Island | Dream Island | Common | 10% |
| Fallen StarDream Island | Dream Island | Legendary | 1 in 200 |
| Fire RayInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Rare | 6.29% |
| Flame SeahorseInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Legendary | 1 in 500 |
| FlamefishInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Rare | 4.14% |
| Frost TroutBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 7.89% |
| Frostbite BarracudaBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 7.39% |
| Frozen CatfishBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Rare | 5.2% |
| Giant SquidPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Legendary | 1 in 6,667 |
| Glacier BassBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 9.52% |
| GlassfishBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Rare | 6.78% |
| Golden KoiFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Legendary | 1 in 200 |
| Golden LionfishInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Rare | 5.4% |
| Green Brick FishClassic Island | Classic Island | Common | 11.7% |
| Green Moray EelPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Epic | 1.82% |
| Guardian SharkLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Epic | 1 in 111 |
| Guineafowl PufferfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Epic | 1.25% |
| Hammerhead SharkPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Epic | 1 in 110 |
| Heated PerchInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Common | 9.72% |
| Hermit CrabLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Legendary | 1 in 500 |
| Ice MinnowBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 8.87% |
| Ice PikeBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Epic | 3.29% |
| Icejaw EelBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Legendary | 1 in 400 |
| King SquidLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Legendary | 1 in 50,000 |
| Koromo KoiFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Epic | 3.56% |
| Lava BlackdragonInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Rare | 3.6% |
| Lava PiercerInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Rare | 4.86% |
| Lemon SharkFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Legendary | 1 in 500 |
| LionfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Legendary | 1% |
| Marine LoachLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Common | 17.8% |
| Marine SnapperLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Common | 11.7% |
| Molten DevilfishInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Legendary | 1 in 10,000 |
| Moonlit CarpBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Epic | 2% |
| MudfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Common | 8.1% |
| Mystic CarpDream Island | Dream Island | Common | 9.1% |
| Mystic PerchDream Island | Dream Island | Rare | 8.29% |
| Mystic PrickerDream Island | Dream Island | Rare | 7.4% |
| Mystic SeahorseDream Island | Dream Island | Rare | 6.86% |
| Mystic SnapperDream Island | Dream Island | Rare | 5.14% |
| Mystique RayDream Island | Dream Island | Rare | 3.6% |
| Mythical KoiDream Island | Dream Island | Legendary | 1 in 1,000 |
| Northern Red SnapperPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 7.65% |
| OarfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Legendary | 1 in 400 |
| Ombre ChevalierInfernite Volcano | Infernite Volcano | Common | 10.3% |
| Pacific BlackdragonPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Epic | 1 in 183 |
| Pale PerchBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 8.21% |
| PerchFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Common | 8.75% |
| PermitFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Common | 7.78% |
| Pink SalmonPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 9.29% |
| Planar EelDream Island | Dream Island | Epic | 2.7% |
| Platinum TunaDream Island | Dream Island | Epic | 2% |
| Poseidon's RelicLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Legendary | 1 in 66,667 |
| Purple Brick FishClassic Island | Classic Island | Common | 9.1% |
| Queen ParrotfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Rare | 3.5% |
| Queen SnapperFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Epic | 3.24% |
| Rainbow Brick FishClassic Island | Classic Island | Epic | 2.7% |
| Rainbow SnapperLost Atlantis | Lost Atlantis | Epic | 2% |
| Red Brick FishClassic Island | Classic Island | Common | 17.8% |
| Reef FishBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Legendary | 1 in 200 |
| River CarpFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Rare | 5.18% |
| RockfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Epic | 1.62% |
| RoosterfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Rare | 4.38% |
| SailfishPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Rare | 5.46% |
| SalmonFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Common | 7.29% |
| Sand MinnowPoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Common | 10.4% |
| Scarlet SailfishDream Island | Dream Island | Epic | 1.53% |
| SeahorsePoison Jungle | Poison Jungle | Legendary | 1 in 1,333 |
| SeastarDream Island | Dream Island | Epic | 1.25% |
| Shiver RayBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Epic | 1.31% |
| Shortbill SpearfishFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Epic | 2.43% |
| ShrimpFisher's Island | Fisher's Island | Epic | 1.94% |
| Silver ShadBlizzard Hills | Blizzard Hills | Common | 10.7% |
| Sky DevilfishDream Island | Dream Island | Legendary | 1 in 20,000 |
| Sky LionfishDream Island | Dream Island | Epic | 1 in 111 |
